HOUND ASSOCIATION OF SCOTLAND 2010

CRITIQUE
I THOROUGHLY ENJOYED JUDGING AT THIS LEVEL FOR THE FIRST TIME AND THANK ALL WHO CONTIBUTED TO MAKING IT SUCH A SPECIAL  DAY. MY GENERAL IMPRESSION OF THE DOGS THAT CAME BEFORE ME  WAS GOOD; IN SOME CASES I FORGAVE EXHIBITS FOR BEING A LITTLE  BIGGER THAN I WOULD HAVE PREFERED IN ORDER TO REWARD BREED TYPE AND MOVEMENT. OVERALL I FELT THAT THE DEPTH OF QUALITY WAS BETTER IN THE BITCHES THAN DOGS BUT HAVING SAID THAT I WAS PLEASED WITH MY WINNERS IN BOTH SEXES. THE MAJORITY OF EXHIBITS HAD THE CORRECT DEPTH OF BRISKET AND GOOD FILL IN WHICH I FEEL WAS LACKING A FEW YEARS BACK. THE MOST COMMON FAULT THAT I SAW WAS POOR HINDMOVEMENT WITH SOME MOVING VERY CLOSE BEHIND, THIS WEAKNESS DID NOT SEEM TO COME FROM LACK OF MUSCLE TONE AND IN FACT SOME EXHIBITS WERE SO MUSCLED AS TO DETRACT FROM THE ELEGANCE OF THE BREED. IT  WAS PLEASING TO SEE THAT DENTITION WAS GOOD THROUGHOUT.

Minor Puppy - Dog

Entries: 5 Absentees: 1
1st
LANAKESHENA LOVE IN MOTION AT VEREDON (MR R P SYKES) F/W
 
WELL BALANCED AND MOVING WELL FOR HIS AGE, QUALITY HEAD

CARRIED ON GOOD LENGTH OF NECK, NICE BONE AND FEET,

GOOD QUARTERS, NEEDS TO LEARN TO STAND OVER A BIT MORE

GROUND. BPD

2nd
RAILFIELD RAINHAWK (MR & MRS T K ELLIS) ANOTHER

QUALITY

F/W WITH SIMULAR ATTRIBUTES, JUST MORE RAW THAN THE

WINNER IT WILL BE INTERSTING TO SEE HOW THE TWO OF THEM

MATURE.

3rd
NEVEDITH ROYAL RAKE (MISS E W NEWTON)
 
Puppy - Dog

Entries: 7 Absentees: 0
1st
COLLOONEY DUTCH COURAGE (MISS N ERWIN) QUALITY BR/W

WITH GOOD TOP AND UNDERLINES, PLEASING HEAD ALTHOUGH

UNDERJAW A LITTLE WEAK, GOOD QUARTERS WHICH HE USED

WELL TO PRODUCE CORRECT PROFILE MOVEMENT, PRESENTED

IN LOVELY CONDITION AND GOOD FOR SIZE.

2nd
DEMERLAY HATS OFF TO LARRY (MRS M HEAD) NICELEY

BALANCED F/W WITH GOOD FRONT CONSTRUCTION, CORRECT

OUTLINE AND GOOD SWEEP OF STIFFLE, HOCKS WELL LET

DOWN, WELL BODIED FOR HIS AGE, MOVED WELL IN PROFILE.

3rd
BERWICKLAW HARBOUR MASTER (MRS N THOMSON)

Junior - Dog

Entries: 8 Absentees: 0
1st
CROSSCOP REASON TO BELIEVE JW (L & S MORRIS & WADDELL)

BR/W PARTI GOOD FOR SIZE, TYPE AND BALANCE. CORRECT

BONE AND FEET, GOOD HEAD, EYES AND EARS, CORRECT REAR

ASSEMBLY, MOVED WELL.

2nd
TURNSTONE CRACKAWAY JACK JW (MR J & MRS V TURNBULL)

ANOTHER QUALITY YOUNGSTER, GOOD THROUGH HEAD, NECK

AND SHOULDER, STOOD OVER PLENTY OF GROUND, NICE

UNDERLINE, MOVED OUT WELL.

3rd
MILLWOLD MAKE A MOVE TO BOARLEY (MRS L STRUNIN)

Yearling - Dog

Entries: 3 Absentees: 0
1st
KORDALINE JESSE JAMES JW (MRS S & MR A J COUSINS &

TIPPING) FBR/W IN SUPER CONDITION, GOOD HEAD, EYES AND

EARS, CORRECT LAY OF SHOULDER, TOPLINE, BONE AND FEET,

GOOD SPRING OF RIB, STRONG WELL CONSTRUCTED QUARTERS

WHICH HE USED TO HIS ADVANTAGE IN PROFILE MOVEMENT.

2nd
WHISTERFIELD JACK BE NIMBLE (MS C A PRICE) BL FAWN OF

LOVELY SHAPE AND MAKE, GOOD THROUGH HEAD, NECK,

SHOULDER AND UPPER ARM, CORRECT SHAPED QUARTERS WITH

GOOD DEPTH THROUGH SECOND THIGH, MOVED WELL IN

PROFILE.

3rd
DELJORHEA MYSTIC MAN (MRS J MCKENZIE)

Post Graduate - Dog

Entries: 6 Absentees: 1

1st
STORMALONG BLACKOUT (MRS C NEALE) BLACK DOG IN

GLEAMING CONDITION, NICE HEAD AND EXPRESSION, SUPER

FRONT ASSEMBLY, GOOD OUTLINE, CORRECT BONE AND FEET,

GOOD THROUGH THIGH AND SECOND THIGH WITH CORRECT

TURN OF STIFFLE.

2nd
ELMANASH AMBERJACK OF SHAGRAAN (MRS F CAMMOILE)

RB/W PRESENTED IN REALLY GOOD HARD CONDITION, NICE

HEAD AND EYES, CORRECT BONE AND PLEASING OUTLINE.

3rd
COLLOONEY TRICKY DICKY (MR L JOHNSTON)

Mid Limit - Dog

Entries: 8 Absentees: 0

1st
WELSTAR WITH STRAUSS (MRS L M JONES) SUPER FOR TYPE AND

IN LOVELY CONDITION, CORRECT HEAD WITH GOOD

EYE AND EXPRESSION, CORRECT EARS, NECK AND FRONT

ASSEMBLY, GOOD TOPLINE WHICH FLOWED NICELY INTO

STRONG QUARTERS, MOVED WELL.

2nd
DEMERLAY RYTHMNBLUES (MRS M HEAD) ANOTHER FAWN OF

SIMULAR TYPE TO THE WINNER AND SAME REMARKS APPLY.

MOVED WELL IN PROFILE.

3rd
MIDNIGHT DAZZLER AT DEROHAN (MRS C OSBORNE)

Limit - Dog

Entries: 10 Absentees: 0
1st
BENZFREYA DRUMBEAT JW SHCM (MISS S WILKINSON) HERE

WAS MY STAR OF THE DOGS, PALE BRINDLE WITH WHITE TRIM

IN SUPER CONDITION. GREAT FOR BREED TYPE AND OVERALL

BALANCE, LOVELY ELEGANT HEAD WITH CORRECT EYES AND

EARS, JUST THE RIGHT REACH OF NECK WHICH FLOWED INTO

WELL LAID SHOULDERS WITH THE CORRECT RETURN OF UPPER

ARM, SUPER BODY, DEPTH OF BRISKET AND FILL WITHOUT

BEING OVERDONE, STRONG QUARTERS WITH THE CORRECT

ANGLES AND DEPTH THROUGH THIGHS, MOVED TRUE AND WITH

GREAT LOW REACHING STRIDES. DCC.

2nd
SPINNEYHILL RAINMAKER OF RAILFIELD (MR & MRS T K

ELLIS) THIS DOG WAS UNLUCKY TO MEET THE WINNER, HE HAS

ALL OF THE ESSENTIALS THAT MAKE A GOOD WHIPPET.

3rd
COLLOONEY MOCHACCHINO (MRS C MARTIN)

Open - Dog

Entries: 8 Absentees: 0

1st
CH NUT CHIP OF NEVEDITH JW (MISS E W NEWTON) A

FAVOURITE OF MINE WHO I HAVE LONG ADMIRED HE HEADED A

CLASS OF QUALITY DOGS. BL FAWN WITH WHITE TRIM, GOOD

FOR SIZE, HEAD, EARS, EYES, REACH OF NECK, LAY OF

SHOULDER AND UPPER ARM, FLOWING OUTLINE AND STRONG

QUARTERS WHICH HE USED TO HIS ADVANTAGE ON THE MOVE. RDCC

2nd
LOROLI AUTHORIZED BY DEROHAN JW (MRS C OSBORNE)

BRINDLE WHOSE COLOUR DOES NOT HELP HIM, THIS IS A DOG

THAT YOU REALLY NEED TO GET YOUR HANDS ON TO

APPRECIATE, LOVELY TYPE AND GOOD ALL THROUGH,

PRESENTED IN SUPER CONDITION AND MOVED WELL.

3rd
WRENALLA JUST GILES AT TRIKEN (MRS P M & MRS A, & MR R DUFTY, MORLAND-ALLEN & MOR)

Minor Puppy - Bitch

Entries: 8 Absentees: 1

1st
ASHVILLEBUR JACKS JEWEL (MS C A PRICE) VERY PRETTY

FAWN BABY WITH ALL OF THE ESSENTIALS, JUST NEEDS TO

GROW ON. MOVED WELL FOR HER AGE.

2nd
CEDARIDGE VANILLA SKIES OVER VEREDON (MR R P SYKES)

BLUE FAWN AGAIN VERY FEMININE A JUST A BABY, GOOD ALL

THROUGH, I WILL WATCH BOTH OF THEIR FUTURES WITH

INTEREST.
 

3rd
NEVEDITH ROYAL ROMANCE (MR & MRS J MCLEOD)

Puppy - Bitch

Entries: 9 Absentees: 0

1st
CROSSCOP HEAVEN SENT TO COLLOONEY (MS V COULTER)

RF/W GOOD HEAD WITH NICE EYE AND EXPRESSION, GOOD

REACH OF NECK WITH CORRECT SHOULDER AND UPPER ARM

PLACEMENT, ADEQUATE RISE OVER THE LOIN FOR HER AGE,

GOOD QUARTERS WITH NICE SWEEP OF STIFFLE AND GOOD

WIDTH ACROSS THIGHS, MOVED WELL FOR A PUP. BP

2nd
JENAUL JAZMIN AT BENZFREYA (MISS S WILKINSON) FEMINE

PUPPY OF GOOD SIZE AND CORRECT BONE, ELEGANT HEAD,

GOOD NECK, SHOULD AND UPPER ARM, WELL DEVELOPED

QUARTERS FOR A PUPPY, STILL NEEDING TO SETTLE ON THE

MOVE.

3rd
COLLOONEY TARTAN TART (MR & MRS D G SHORT)

Junior - Bitch

Entries: 13 Absentees: 0
1st
PALMIK MAGICAL WHISPERS JW (MR M & MS Y HOWGATE &

HULL) BR/WH TRIM, VERY SOUND YOUNG BITCH WITH LOVELY

HEAD, GOOD THROUGH NECK, SHOULDER AND UPPER ARM,

CORRECT BONE AND FEET, GOOD QUARTERS.

2nd
COLLOONEY STEP ASIDE (MS V COULTER) VERY ATTRACTIVE

BRINDLE BITCH WHO WAS CLOSE UP TO THE WINNER AND

SIMILAR REMARKS APPLY.

3rd
MILLWOLD MULLING IT OVER (MISS M DIXON)

Yearling - Bitch

Entries: 13 Absentees: 2
1st
PEPERONE POT OF GOLD JW (MR & MRS J MCLEOD) F PARTI

GOOD FOR SIZE AND TYPE, NICE REACH OF NECK AND PLEASING

FRONT ASSEMBLY, GOOD BONE AND TOPLINE, STRONG

QUARTERS WITH GOOD SECOND THIGHS AND WELL LET DOWN

HOCKS.

2nd
MULCAIR MUSICAL MELODY (MRS J A WHITAKER-CROSBY)

PALE FAWN BITCH OF LOVELY TYPE, SIMPLY GOOD ALL

THROUGH AND SO SOUND.

3rd
CHELRIDGE CHARLIES ANGEL (MRS W P SPENCER)

Post Graduate - Bitch

Entries: 16 Absentees: 1

1st
COLLOONEY SOME LIKE IT HOT SHCM (K & S MCKINNON)

BR/W TRIM GOOD FOR SIZE AND TYPE, LOVELY HEAD, EYE AND

EXPRESSION, GOOD NECK AND FRONT ASSEMBLY, CORRECT

BONE AND FEET, LOVELY OUTLINE, STRONG WELL BUILT

QUARTERS. MOVED WELL.

2nd
TURNSTONE HOT TO TROT (MR J & MRS V TURNBULL) VERY

FEMININE  BITCH BUILT ON SLIGHTLY LONGER LINES THAN THE

WINNER OTHERWISE SIMILAR REMARKS APPLY, I FEEL THAT

THEY COULD CHANGE PLACES ANOTHER DAY.

3rd

SUFEINA HEDGE ABOUT (MRS A FABER)

Mid Limit - Bitch

Entries: 19 Absentees: 3
1st
NEW NOVELTY OF NEVEDITH (MISS E W NEWTON) BL/W TRIM

SUPER TYPE OF WHIPPET, VERY ELEGANT, QUALITY HEAD, GOOD

NECK, SHOULDER AND UPPER ARM, LOVELY OUTLINE, STRONG

QUARTERS WITH GOOD SECOND THIGH AND WELL LET DOWN

HOCKS, MOVED WELL.

2nd
MULCAIR MUMS THE WORD JW (MRS J A WHITAKER-CROSBY)

BR PARTI IN SUPER CONDITION, ANOTHER QUALITY YOUNG

BITCH, VERY CLOSE UP TO THE WINNER,
3rd
SPINNEYHILL SONGBIRD (MRS A RANDALL)

Limit - Bitch

Entries: 19 Absentees: 4

1st
PALMIK MIDNIGHT MISCHIEF JW (MR M & MS Y HOWGATE &

HULL) PALE FAWN BITCH OF SUPER QUALITY AND BREED TYPE,

ELEGANT HEAD WITH CORRECT EARS, GOOD REACH OF NECK,

SUPER FRONT ASSEMBLY, CORRECT TOPLINE WHICH FLOWS

INTO STRONG WELL MADE QUARTERS. MOVED REALLY WELL.

2nd

TRADEWIND TOUCH OF MAGIC SHCM (MRS C LEDGER)

ANOTHER OF CORRECT MAKE AND SHAPE, VERY GOOD ON THE

MOVE AND SAME REMARKS APPLY AS TO CLASS WINNER.

3rd

TRIKEN TIMELESS STAR (MRS P M & MRS A, & MR R DUFTY, MORLAND-ALLEN & MOR)

Open - Bitch

Entries: 8 Absentees: 1

1st
CH HUNTINGHILL JAZZALICIOUS JW (MRS A E & MISS R C

SNELGROVE) LOVELY F/W SO SHAPELY AND ELEGANT,

PRESENTED IN SUPER CONDITION. HEAD IS CARRIED ON A

STRONG NECK OF JUST THE RIGHT PROPORTIONS WHICH FLOWS

INTO WELL LAID SHOULDERS WITH CORRECT RETURN OF

UPPER ARM. GOOD BONE AND FEET, CORRECT SPRING OF RIB

AND DEPTH OF BRISKET, STRONG QUARTERS WITH GOOD SWEEP

OF STIFLE WITH WELL LET DOWN HOCKS, SHE MOVED REALLY

WELL BOTH IN THE BREED AND IN THE CHALLENGE FOR BIS. BCC

BOB AND BIS THREE.

 
2nd
PEPERONE PIERIS (MR & MRS J MCLEOD) QUALITY BITCH WHO

WAS UNLUCKY TO MEET THE CLASS WINNER, SHE IS ANOTHER

ONE WELL CONSTRUCTED THROUGH OUT WITH GOOD HEAD,

EYES AND EARS AND HAS SUPER PROFILE MOVEMENT. RBCC.

 
3rd
SPINNEYHILL GENEVIEVE AT TURNSTONE (MR J & MRS V TURNBULL)